Skip to main content

The Rage to Master: Reminding Teens That Not All Effort Is Equal


When Alysa Liu skated at the Winter Olympics, we saw this remarkably composed young woman with exquisite technical precision.   What we didn’t see on our TV screens was her relationship with skating.  The long hours she spent practicing a skill she both enjoyed and steadily mastered. That combination, liking something, getting better at it, and using it to meet challenge, is a powerful engine of human motivation.

This idea surfaced recently when Reese Witherspoon reflected publicly on the importance of discovering one’s talents. Her point was not about celebrity or success, but about something more ordinary and more consequential: people thrive when they find an activity that feels like a natural fit. Psychologists call this working from one’s strengths.

Research in positive psychology suggests that a true strength has three features. It is something a person enjoys. It is something they do well or improve at with practice. And it is something that provides energy rather than draining it, especially under stress. When these elements come together, they often produce what Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi famously described as “flow” — a state of deep absorption in which effort feels purposeful, and time seems to pass unnoticed.

Elite athletes are obvious examples, but the principle is far broader. A teenager who loves building things and becomes skilled at it may lose herself in design projects. Another who enjoys listening and advising friends may gravitate toward mentoring roles. A student who finds pleasure in solving puzzles may lean into mathematics not because it is easy, but because it is satisfying.

For our teens, understanding this matters more than we realise. Yes, teenagers need to experience struggle - to learn how to tolerate frustration and manage strong emotions.  But struggle alone isn’t enough. They also need spaces where they can use their strengths: activities they genuinely enjoy, skills they can grow with practice, and challenges that energise rather than drain them. These experiences tap into what psychologist Ellen Winner has called the “rage to master” — the intense, intrinsically driven desire to understand and improve in a particular area. When our teens are working from their strengths, they discover that effort doesn’t have to be punishing, it can be engaging, motivating, and even joyful.

Yet many of our teens do not encounter these experiences in school. Classrooms are built around standardised skills and shared curricula. For some teens, this structure aligns neatly with their strengths. For others, it does not. A teenager whose gifts lie in performance, mechanics, or leadership may pass years without seeing those capacities reflected or rewarded. The result is not only boredom, but a quieter erosion of confidence: a sense that learning itself is the problem.

This gap is hard on us as well. We watch our kids slog through material that does not seem to fit them and wonder when, or whether, they will find the place where effort feels worthwhile.

The lesson is not that every teenager needs a passion by age sixteen. It is that they need to understand that development is uneven and often delayed. Many adults trace their sense of competence and purpose to experiences found only after formal schooling ended: in work, in relationships, or in unexpected interests.

What our teens need in the meantime is reassurance that struggle in the wrong setting does not define them.

 

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why Boredom Is the Best Thing About Summer for Our Kids

  We’re only a few weeks into summer, and I’m guessing many of us are already hearing the familiar cry from our kids: “I’m bored!” It’s such a natural parenting instinct to try and fix it right away—we set up activities, we turn on a screen, or we jump in to entertain them. But boredom isn’t something we need to rush to solve. In fact, it can be surprisingly good for our kids’ developing brains. Boredom is like your brain’s way of nudging you and saying, “Hey, let’s go find something new to do!.”  And it doesn’t feel great but when our kids sit with that feeling instead of escaping it, their brains start connecting old ideas with new ones. That mix of daydreaming and problem-solving is exactly how creativity begins. And something powerful happens when our kids work out what to do on their own. They are using the “planning” part of the brain that helps with independence and decision-making. And when they invent their own fun, the brain gives a bigger dose of the feel-good c...
Post a Comment
Read more

When Phone Use Becomes Emotional Coping: What a New Study Reveals About Kids and Screens

  One of the most common clinical questions I get asked is about phones and social media. Many parents (myself included) are grappling with their child’s phone use and wondering whether it’s crossing the line into something more concerning. Our kids live in a world where phones, apps, and social media are deeply woven into daily life — and as parents, it’s incredibly hard to untangle what’s OK from what might be harmful. A new study published in JAMA Pediatrics (June 2025) offers some timely insight — and tentative reassurance — for everyone trying to navigate this challenge. This large-scale study followed more than 4,300 children aged 8 to 12 over four years. The researchers weren’t just measuring how much time kids spent on their phones — they were also looking at what they described as addictive patterns of use . Importantly, addictive behaviours didn’t simply mean spending lots of time on phones or social media. It meant compulsive, emotionally fraught patterns of use,...
Post a Comment
Read more

The 5:1 Rule: A Simple Way to Stay Connected with Your Teen

  If you’re parenting a tween or teen, you’ve probably felt it — that slow shift as they start pulling away. The chats get shorter, the eye rolls more frequent, and suddenly the door to their room is shut more often than it’s open. This is a normal (and healthy) part of growing up. Our kids are figuring out who they are, and part of that process means leaning more on their friends and less on us. But it’s hard.   And we know that conflict comes with the territory when we are raising teenagers.   Whether it’s about phones, school stress, or staying out too late, the opportunities for conflict are pretty high. Without meaning to, a lot of our communication can start to sound like nagging, correcting, or reminding. Even neutral comments like “Did you do your homework?” or “Don’t forget your shoes” can come across as criticism. This is where holding on to the 5:1 rule can be super helpful.     It comes from Dr. John Gottman, who has studied couples for decades a...
Post a Comment
Read more