Skip to main content

Parenting: Is there a right way?

 



A few weeks ago, I overheard a conversation in a coffee shop.  It was between two mothers in their mid-thirties.  They were speaking about another mother at their school and her approach to parenting.  They recognised the warmth and love she felt for her children but were flabbergasted at her laissez-faire attitude to structure and boundaries.  Essentially, they were describing what psychologists call permissive parenting. 

Diana Baumrind, a developmental psychologist, who identified the three styles of parenting in the 1960’s, defines permissive parents as “more responsive than they are demanding.  They are non-traditional and lenient, allow considerable self-regulation, and do not require mature behaviour”.

Now a days permissive parenting is generally identified by low demands and a high level of responsiveness.  Parents who are incredibly loving and available for their children… who do not place many limits on their children’s behaviour. 

Signs that you may be parenting in a more permissive way

·       Your house is pretty relaxed with very few rules or boundaries

·       You are available and provide lots of emotional support but stop short of placing demands on your child in terms of behaviour, homework, chores etc ….

·       You have a loose structure at home, everyone can pretty much do what they want

·       Your children might describe you as more of a friend than a parent

·       In general, you avoid confrontation with your child whenever possible

 

So, what are the outcomes of permissive parenting? Traditionally permissive parenting was considered detrimental to the outcomes for our children but now we are not so sure.  The research appears to depend on how the researchers define different parenting approaches.  The same parent might be identified as permissive in one study and authoritative in another which makes trusting the research in this area difficult. 

In general permissive parenting is warm and responsive and this is a really good thing for our kids.  It creates connection and secure attachment, increases psychological safety, and reduces stress.  When it comes to the other important aspect of parenting, guidance and limit setting, children of permissive parents may be at a disadvantage. Permissive parenting has been associated with an increase in behaviour problems, substance abuse and a decrease in school performance.    

BUT there is also evidence to suggest that children of permissive parents thrive.  One large study (which has been repeated subsequently) was carried out by Garcia and Garcia in 2009.  It involved 1400 kids being questioned about their parents.   The researchers categorised the parents and identified links between parenting styles and the child’s outcome.  In this study (and many subsequent studies) the teens with the permissive parents were identified as having higher self-esteem, were less likely to see the world as a dangerous place and were more likely to be emotionally engaged. 

The take away…

As the two mothers left the coffee shop, I was left contemplating the vast array of advice that is currently available to parents and how difficult it can be to decipher this research.   Ultimately, I think what matters most is that we understand clearly what is linked to better outcomes for our children.  There is no research that tells us ignoring anti -social behaviour is in our children’s best interest.  There is no research that tells us that our children flourish when they have no autonomy and are told exactly what they can and cannot do.  There is ample research that tells us a warm nurturing relationship with our primary caregiver is beneficial and protective in almost every way imaginable.  Once we are providing consistent nurture and warmth to our children we need to see and understand the child standing in front of us – their temperament, their strengths, their struggles because this is what we need to pay attention to in order to parent in the most advantageous way for each of our individual children.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why do we suddenly feel about 12 when we arrive home for Christmas

  If we are lucky, we had pretty good childhoods — some messy bits, some lovely bits — and yet heading back to our family home can still bring up a lot of tricky feelings. We walk through the door, smell something familiar, hear the same old jokes, and suddenly we feel a bit different. A bit younger. A bit touchier. A bit more sensitive. If that happens to you, it doesn’t mean anything is wrong. It’s simply how our brains work. When we return to places where we learned, grew, argued, and at least partially became who we are, our bodies remember the emotional atmosphere of those years. Psychologists call this “state-dependent memory,” and what it means is that certain rooms, voices, and routines wake up old emotional patterns — even if our adult lives feel stable and healthy. Our families also have a way of nudging us back into our old roles without meaning to. Maybe we were the bossy one, or the peacemaker, or the “easy” child who didn’t make waves. We might not play those role...

Parenting: Looking Back on a Tricky Christmas with Teens.

  In my clinic, in the weeks after Christmas, a familiar pattern often emerges in conversations with parents of teenagers. There is disappointment that time together felt tense rather than warm, or that connection seemed harder to reach. Many of us find ourselves wondering whether this is simply how things are now, or whether something has gone wrong. For families with teenagers, a difficult Christmas is not a sign of failure. Christmas amplifies everything. Routines fall away, sleep patterns change, social demands increase, and private space shrinks. At the same time, expectations rise. As parents, we desperately want closeness, fun, and shared moments. For our teens — who are already managing heightened emotions and a growing need for independence — this combination can feel overwhelming. Developmental psychology helps make sense of this. We know our teens experience emotions more intensely than we do, and we know the brain systems responsible for emotional regulation, impulse co...

The Rage to Master: Reminding Teens That Not All Effort Is Equal

When Alysa Liu skated at the Winter Olympics, we saw this remarkably composed young woman with exquisite technical precision.   What we didn’t see on our TV screens was her relationship with skating.  The long hours she spent practicing a skill she both enjoyed and steadily mastered. That combination, liking something, getting better at it, and using it to meet challenge, is a powerful engine of human motivation. This idea surfaced recently when Reese Witherspoon reflected publicly on the importance of discovering one’s talents. Her point was not about celebrity or success, but about something more ordinary and more consequential: people thrive when they find an activity that feels like a natural fit. Psychologists call this working from one’s strengths. Research in positive psychology suggests that a true strength has three features. It is something a person enjoys. It is something they do well or improve at with practice. And it is something that provides energy rather ...